Hi Razvan,
are you sure this new support of provisioning via DB is supported by tools "opensipctldb create", because new table "rtpengine" does not exist when I create a new database from scratch.
thanks
https://github.com/OpenSIPS/opensips/commit/094c850dd91286ff75bf3463dafbf83a398aaf8f
Le 12/07/2018 11:58, « Users au nom de Alain Bieuzent » <users-bounces at lists.opensips.org au nom de alain.bieuzent at free.fr> a écrit :
    Hi all,
    
    
    
    I just created a new database and version of table rtpproxy_sockets is 0, so i think there is a mismatch somewhere because opensips 2.4.1 expected 1.
    
    
    
    Is there somewhere the mysql schema of 2.4 version?
    
    
    
    thanks
    
    
    
    Le 11/07/2018 18:02, « Users au nom de Răzvan Crainea » <users-bounces at lists.opensips.org au nom de razvan at opensips.org> a écrit :
    
    
    
        No problem, thanks for sharing the initial cause!
    
        
    
        Best regards,
    
        Răzvan
    
        
    
        On 07/11/2018 06:59 PM, Alain Bieuzent wrote:
    
        > never forgot to check the logs.....
    
        > 
    
        > yes, you are right opensips didn't start with this error:
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > Jul 11 17:52:21 opensips-test opensips[20625]: ERROR:core:db_check_table_version: invalid version 0 for table rtpproxy_sockets found, expected 1
    
        > 
    
        > Jul 11 17:52:21 opensips-test opensips[20625]: ERROR:rtpengine:mod_init: error during table version check
    
        > 
    
        > Jul 11 17:52:21 opensips-test opensips[20625]: ERROR:core:init_mod: failed to initialize module rtpengine
    
        > 
    
        > Jul 11 17:52:21 opensips-test opensips[20625]: ERROR:core:main: error while initializing modules
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > My fault sorry for the noise.
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > Thanks, Razvan.
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > Le 11/07/2018 17:48, « Users au nom de Răzvan Crainea » <users-bounces at lists.opensips.org au nom de razvan at opensips.org> a écrit :
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        >      Hello!
    
        > 
    
        >      
    
        > 
    
        >      After you comment the first line, can you make sure opensips actually
    
        > 
    
        >      starts (ps aux | grep opensips). After that, can you check that the
    
        > 
    
        >      /tmp/opensips_fifo file exists?
    
        > 
    
        >      
    
        > 
    
        >      Best regards,
    
        > 
    
        >      Răzvan
    
        > 
    
        >      
    
        > 
    
        >      On 07/11/2018 06:37 PM, Alain Bieuzent wrote:
    
        > 
    
        >      > Hi, Rasvan!
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > I double check and the typo with the "i" is not the cause.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > I used these parameters:
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > ######################################################################
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > #### RTPENGINE module
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > ######################################################################
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > modparam("rtpengine", "rtpengine_sock", "udp:10.207.201.19:2223 udp:10.207.201.20:2223")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > modparam("rtpengine", "db_url", "mysql://opensips:XXXX@ZZZ/opensips_lb_did_2_4")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > modparam("rtpengine", "db_table", "rtpproxy_sockets")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > modparam("rtpengine", "socket_column", "rtpproxy_sock")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > modparam("rtpengine", "set_column", "set_id")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > If i comment the 4 last line to do not use db, opensips start i can use opensipsctl fifo ds_list (so no issue with fifo file)
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > If i comment only the first line to use db, opensipsctl produce the error about fifo file.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > I don't change anything else except comment the first or the last 4 line.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > I don't know where to look ..
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > thanks for your help
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > Le 11/07/2018 16:24, « Users au nom de Răzvan Crainea » <users-bounces at lists.opensips.org au nom de razvan at opensips.org> a écrit :
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Hi, Alain!
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      I think Pasan is right, you are either using a different
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      /tmp/opensips_fifo modparam, or you can't access that file with the user
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      you are trying to run. Or, perhaps you have a syntax error in your
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      configuration file, and OpenSIPS doesn't start at all, that's why
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      opensipsctl reports it cannot find the fifo file.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      If I am looking better at the snippet you posted, I see an "i" before a
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      comment there:
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >        i#modparam("rtpengine", "rtpengine_sock", "udp:10.207.201.20:2223")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      That could be a parsing error which might prevent opensips from
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      starting, thus creating the fifo file.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Did you check if the file is actually there after you get the
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      opensipsctl error?
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Best regards,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Răzvan
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      On 07/11/2018 03:55 PM, Alain Bieuzent wrote:
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Hi all,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > nobody has any other idea?
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Thanks
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *De : *Users <users-bounces at lists.opensips.org> au nom de Alain Bieuzent
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > <alain.bieuzent at free.fr>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *Répondre à : *OpenSIPS users mailling list <users at lists.opensips.org>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *Date : *vendredi 6 juillet 2018 à 14:06
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *À : *Pasan Meemaduma <pasandev at ymail.com>, OpenSIPS users mailling list
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > <users at lists.opensips.org>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *Objet : *Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] RTPengine provisioning by db
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Hi Pasan,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Thanks for the reply but yes of course I have mi_fifo module load and
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > configure.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > I’m using also dispatcher with a db provisioning and without the db
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > parameters for the rtpengine module I can manage the dispatcher entry
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > via opensipsctl fi ds_XXXX
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > with the the db parameters for the rtpengine module, command opensipsctl
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > fifo ds_list provide the same error about mi_fifo.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > thanks
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *De : *Users <users-bounces at lists.opensips.org> au nom de Pasan
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Meemaduma via Users <users at lists.opensips.org>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *Répondre à : *Pasan Meemaduma <pasandev at ymail.com>, OpenSIPS users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > mailling list <users at lists.opensips.org>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *Date : *vendredi 6 juillet 2018 à 12:23
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *À : *OpenSIPS users mailling list <users at lists.opensips.org>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > *Objet : *Re: [OpenSIPS-Users] RTPengine provisioning by db
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Hi Alain,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > do you have following config lines in your opensips.cfg file which
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > enables the fifo management interface ?
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > loadmodule "mi_fifo.so"
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > # ----- mi_fifo params -----
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > modparam("mi_fifo", "fifo_name", "/tmp/opensips_fifo")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > According to the error you got it doesn't seems to exists.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > On Friday, 6 July 2018, 3:27:51 PM GMT+5:30, Alain Bieuzent
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > <alain.bieuzent at free.fr> wrote:
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Hi all,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > I’m trying to provionning rtpengine via mysql db, but i can’t add a new
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > proxy via opensipctl
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > My parameters are :
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > ######################################################################
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > #### RTPENGINE module
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > ######################################################################
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > #modparam("rtpengine", "rtpengine_sock", "udp:10.207.201.19:2223
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > udp:10.207.201.20:2223")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > i#modparam("rtpengine", "rtpengine_sock", "udp:10.207.201.20:2223")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > modparam("rtpengine", "db_url",
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > "mysql://opensips:XXXXXXXX@ZZZZZZZZZZZ/opensips_lb_did_2_4")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > modparam("rtpengine", "db_table", "rtpproxy_sockets")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > modparam("rtpengine", "socket_column", "rtpproxy_sock")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > modparam("rtpengine", "set_column", "set_id")
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > when i run : opensipsctl fifo rtpengine_show
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > i received this error :
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > ERROR: /tmp/opensips_fifo does not exist
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > ERROR: Make sure you have the line 'modparam("mi_fifo", "fifo_name",
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > "/tmp/opensips_fifo")' in your config
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > ERROR: and also have loaded the mi_fifo module.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > When i use « rtpengine_sock », it works
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > version: opensips 2.4.1 (x86_64/linux)
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > flags: STATS: On, DISABLE_NAGLE, USE_MCAST, SHM_MMAP, PKG_MALLOC,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > F_MALLOC, FAST_LOCK-ADAPTIVE_WAIT
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > ADAPTIVE_WAIT_LOOPS=1024, MAX_RECV_BUFFER_SIZE 262144, MAX_LISTEN 16,
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > MAX_URI_SIZE 1024, BUF_SIZE 65535
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > poll method support: poll, epoll, sigio_rt, select.
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > git revision: 5d042cffc
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > main.c compiled on 09:17:20 Jul  6 2018 with gcc 4.7
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Someone can help me ?
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > thanks
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > _______________________________________________
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Users at lists.opensips.org <mailto:Users at lists.opensips.org>
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > _______________________________________________ Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > _______________________________________________ Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > _______________________________________________
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      > http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      --
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Răzvan Crainea
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      OpenSIPS Core Developer
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >         http://www.opensips-solutions.com
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      _______________________________________________
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >      http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      > _______________________________________________
    
        > 
    
        >      > Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      > Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > 
    
        >      > http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      >
    
        > 
    
        >      
    
        > 
    
        >      --
    
        > 
    
        >      Răzvan Crainea
    
        > 
    
        >      OpenSIPS Core Developer
    
        > 
    
        >         http://www.opensips-solutions.com
    
        > 
    
        >      
    
        > 
    
        >      _______________________________________________
    
        > 
    
        >      Users mailing list
    
        > 
    
        >      Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > 
    
        >      http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        >      
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > 
    
        > _______________________________________________
    
        > Users mailing list
    
        > Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        > http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        > 
    
        
    
        -- 
    
        Răzvan Crainea
    
        OpenSIPS Core Developer
    
           http://www.opensips-solutions.com
    
        
    
        _______________________________________________
    
        Users mailing list
    
        Users at lists.opensips.org
    
        http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
    
        
    
    
    
    
    _______________________________________________
    Users mailing list
    Users at lists.opensips.org
    http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users