[OpenSIPS-Users] opensips + rtpproxy bridge on loopback interfaces
Răzvan Crainea
razvan at opensips.org
Thu Oct 27 16:23:44 CEST 2016
After a long debugging session with Cedric, we managed to track down the
issue. Apparantely rtpproxy assumes that all sessions are asymetric when
using bridge mode. That's why if you are using symmetric clients, you
have to force the 's' flag, as oposted to normal scenarios.
I've updated the documentation in this direction.
Best regards,
Răzvan Crainea
OpenSIPS Solutions
www.opensips-solutions.com
On 10/26/2016 05:06 PM, Cédric ML wrote:
> Hi Razvan,
>
> Le 26/10/2016 à 15:35, Răzvan Crainea a écrit :
>> Hi, Cedric!
>>
>> If you double checked the PCAP and you really are missing the flow
>> from RTPProxy to callee, I take your word for it. Pehaps the logging
>> is misleading.
>>
>> Now, if RTPProxy does not send any packet to the callee, this means
>> that it doesn't get any packets from him. This means that there is
>> something wrong with the flow from callee to RTPProxy
>> (192.168.157.141:12704 to 192.168.157.121:17226). If you see it in
>> the PCAP on the RTPProxy machine, it might be blocked at the firewall
>> level?
> There is no firewall anywhere (for testing purpose, of course).
> I can see the flow from the callee (192.168.157.141) to rtpproxy
> (192.168.157.121) in the capture, and this flow is relayed correctly
> to the "external" side of rtpproxy.
>>
>> Another thing that you could try: I saw that you are passing the "a"
>> flag to the rtpproxy functions. Do you really need it? Can you try to
>> remove it and test again?
> I tried this morning : I have the same problem. I've tried
> with/without flags "o" & "c" too.
> Tried with rtpproxy on a different host too (adjusting socket
> parameter, of course) : same result.
>
> I'll sent you the last capture I've done a few minutes ago.
> Thanks again for your help.
> Regards,
> Cédric
>
>>
>> Best regards,
>>
>> Răzvan Crainea
>> OpenSIPS Solutions
>> www.opensips-solutions.com
>>
>> On 10/26/2016 03:46 PM, Cédric ML wrote:
>>> Hello Razvan,
>>>
>>> Le 26/10/2016 à 13:52, Răzvan Crainea a écrit :
>>>> Hi, Cedric!
>>>>
>>>> Are you sure that the flows you do not see are the ones you
>>>> mentioned? According to the logs, you do not see the RTP coming
>>>> from the caller:
>>>> RTP stats: 410 in from callee, 0 in from caller
>>> Do these stats work correctly when rtpproxy works in bridge mode ?
>>> Seems like it only watches on "internal" side of bridge, not on
>>> "external" side.
>>>
>>> Caller is 222.251.208.61 (external side, asterisk server), and
>>> callee is 192.168.157.141 (internal side, asterisk server too)
>>> stream from 222.251.208.61:18592 to 111.122.100.20:17826 : OK (rtp
>>> stream from caller to rtpproxy)
>>> stream from 192.168.157.121:17226 to 192.168.157.141:12704 : MISSING
>>> (rtp stream from rtpproxy to callee)
>>> stream from 192.168.157.141:12704 to 192.168.157.121:17226 : OK (rtp
>>> stream from callee to rtpproxy)
>>> stream from 111.122.100.20:17826 to 222.251.208.61:18592 : OK (rtp
>>> stream from rtpproxy to caller)
>>>
>>> So the missing flow is RTP from the rtpproxy to the callee.
>>>>
>>>> So the problem seems to be not on the private network, but on the
>>>> public one. Or there is a reporting bug in RTPProxy :).
>>>>
>>>> What's the user experience for this call? Do any of the
>>>> participants hear each other? Also, where are you doing the trace
>>>> of the RTP?
>>> I'm capturing on the opensips / rtpproxy host.
>>> I can't tell you anything about the user experience, I'm using
>>> asterisk to generate a call ('originate') and stream a sound file,
>>> and the callee is an asterisk too, which just answers and plays a
>>> sound file.
>>>
>>> I can send you an example pcap file if you need it.
>>> Thank you for your help !!!
>>> Best regards,
>>> Cédric
>>>
>>>>
>>>> Best regards,
>>>>
>>>> Răzvan Crainea
>>>> OpenSIPS Solutions
>>>> www.opensips-solutions.com
>>>>
>>>> On 10/26/2016 12:35 PM, Cédric ML wrote:
>>>>> I've made a new test, replacing mediaproxy "external" address by
>>>>> 111.122.100.18 (which is the SIG address).
>>>>> It works fine (rtp stream is complete), but that's not what I'm
>>>>> trying to do. I need to have a different address for the SIG and
>>>>> for the MEDIA.
>>>>> Hope it helps...
>>>>> Regards,
>>>>> Cédric
>>>>>
>>>>> Le 26/10/2016 à 10:39, Cédric ML a écrit :
>>>>>> Hello,
>>>>>> I'm trying to set up opensips (v2.2.2) and rtpproxy
>>>>>> (2.0.beta.20150106) one the same server, using loopback interfaces.
>>>>>> ------------------------------
>>>>>> network config :
>>>>>> lo:2 : inet 111.122.100.18/32 (SIG address)
>>>>>> lo:4 : inet 111.122.100.20/32 (MEDIA address)
>>>>>> eth1 : 192.168.157.121/24
>>>>>> routing :
>>>>>> 222.251.208.61 via 192.168.157.1 dev eth1 src 111.122.100.18
>>>>>> 222.251.120.61 via 192.168.157.1 dev eth1 src 111.122.100.20
>>>>>>
>>>>>> ------------------------------
>>>>>> opensips setup :
>>>>>> listen=udp:0.0.0.0:5060
>>>>>> loadmodule "rtpproxy.so"
>>>>>>
>>>>>> modparam("rtpproxy", "rtpproxy_sock",
>>>>>> "unix:/var/run/rtpproxy/rtpproxy.sock")
>>>>>>
>>>>>> #routing
>>>>>> ...
>>>>>> if (is_method("INVITE")) {
>>>>>> t_on_reply("handle_nat");
>>>>>> $rd="192.168.157.141";
>>>>>> if (has_body("application/sdp"))
>>>>>> {
>>>>>> rtpproxy_offer("afeiroc");
>>>>>> }
>>>>>> }
>>>>>> onreply_route[handle_nat] {
>>>>>> if ( has_body("application/sdp") ){
>>>>>> rtpproxy_answer("afieroc");
>>>>>> }
>>>>>> }
>>>>>> ...
>>>>>> ------------------------------
>>>>>> rtpproxy setup :
>>>>>> /usr/local/bin/rtpproxy -s
>>>>>> unix:/var/run/rtpproxy/rtpproxy.sock -u rtpproxy rtpproxy -p
>>>>>> /var/run/rtpproxy/rtpproxy.pid -l 192.168.157.121 111.122.100.20
>>>>>> -d DBUG LOG_LOCAL5 -m 10000 -M 20000 -w rw
>>>>>> ------------------------------
>>>>>>
>>>>>> When I'm making a call from 222.251.208.61 :
>>>>>> - INVITE arrives on the external side of opensips
>>>>>> (111.122.100.18), SDP contains 222.251.208.61:18592
>>>>>> - INVITE is relayed on the internal side to 192.168.157.141, SDP
>>>>>> is modified to 192.168.157.121:17226
>>>>>> - 200 OK : 192.168.157.141 replies with a 200 OK, SDP contains
>>>>>> 192.168.157.141:12704
>>>>>> - 200 OK : opensips relays 200 OK to 193.252.208.61, SDP is
>>>>>> modified to 111.122.100.20:17826
>>>>>>
>>>>>> So everything looks good in the SDP.
>>>>>> Now looking to the rtp streams :
>>>>>>
>>>>>> stream from 222.251.208.61:18592 to 111.122.100.20:17826 : OK
>>>>>> stream from 192.168.157.121:17226 to 192.168.157.141:12704 : MISSING
>>>>>> stream from 192.168.157.141:12704 to 192.168.157.121:17226 : OK
>>>>>> stream from 111.122.100.20:17826 to 222.251.208.61:18592 : OK
>>>>>>
>>>>>> It seems that rtpproxy fails to bridge the "external -> internal"
>>>>>> part of the media.
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> rtpproxy debug :
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:04 localhost rtpproxy[775]: DBUG:get_command:GLOBAL:
>>>>>> received command "UAEIc8,101
>>>>>> 36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060
>>>>>> 222.251.208.61 18592 as5f5f1868;1"
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:04 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:rtpp_command_ul_handle:GLOBAL: new session
>>>>>> 36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060, tag
>>>>>> as5f5f1868;1 requested, type strong
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:04 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:rtpp_command_ul_handle:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> new session on a port 17226 created, tag as5f5f1868;1
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:04 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:rtpp_command_ul_handle:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> pre-filling caller's address with 222.251.208.61:18592
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:04 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> DBUG:rtpc_doreply:GLOBAL: sending reply "17226 192.168.157.121#012"
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:05 localhost rtpproxy[775]: DBUG:get_command:GLOBAL:
>>>>>> received command "LAIEc8,101
>>>>>> 36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060
>>>>>> 192.168.157.141 12704 as5f5f1868;1 as200acccf;1"
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:05 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:rtpp_command_ul_handle:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> lookup on ports 17226/17826, session timer restarted
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:05 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:rtpp_command_ul_handle:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> pre-filling callee's address with 192.168.157.141:12704
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:05 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> DBUG:rtpc_doreply:GLOBAL: sending reply "17826 111.122.100.20#012"
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:13 localhost rtpproxy[775]: DBUG:get_command:GLOBAL:
>>>>>> received command "D
>>>>>> 36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060 as5f5f1868
>>>>>> as200acccf"
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:13 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:handle_delete:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> forcefully deleting session 1 on ports 17226/17826
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:13 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:remove_session:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> RTP stats: 410 in from callee, 0 in from caller, 410 relayed, 0
>>>>>> dropped
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:13 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:remove_session:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> RTCP stats: 1 in from callee, 0 in from caller, 1 relayed, 0 dropped
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:13 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> INFO:remove_session:36fe8745364f35b61411304154da2db3 at 222.251.208.61:5060:
>>>>>> session on ports 17226/17826 is cleaned up
>>>>>> Oct 26 10:05:13 localhost rtpproxy[775]:
>>>>>> DBUG:rtpc_doreply:GLOBAL: sending reply "0#012"
>>>>>>
>>>>>>
>>>>>> I can't figure out what's wrong in my config. Can you please help
>>>>>> me ?
>>>>>> Should I post this message on rtpproxy mailing list too ?
>>>>>> Best regards,
>>>>>> Cédric
>>>>>
>>>>>
>>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>>> Users mailing list
>>>>> Users at lists.opensips.org
>>>>> http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Users mailing list
>>>> Users at lists.opensips.org
>>>> http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
>>>
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> Users mailing list
>>> Users at lists.opensips.org
>>> http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> Users mailing list
>> Users at lists.opensips.org
>> http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Users mailing list
> Users at lists.opensips.org
> http://lists.opensips.org/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/users
More information about the Users
mailing list